The Importance of Independent Play and Peer Conflict Resolution for Preschool and Kindergarten Children
Play is an essential part of children's development, as it allows them to explore, learn, create, and express themselves in various ways. However, play is not only a source of joy and fun, but also a potential arena for conflict and challenge. Children may encounter disagreements, frustrations, or difficulties when they play with their peers, such as sharing toys, taking turns, following rules, or coping with different preferences and opinions. How can children learn to deal with these conflicts in a constructive and respectful way? And what is the role of adults in supporting children's play and conflict resolution?
Some researchers and educators have argued that children benefit from having opportunities to engage in independent play and solve conflicts with their peers without adult intervention, unless there is an extreme situation in the conflict like the children hitting each other. Independent play refers to play that is self-chosen and self-directed by the child, without adult guidance or interference. Peer conflict resolution refers to the process of finding a mutually acceptable solution to a problem or disagreement between two or more children, without adult mediation or arbitration.
According to these proponents of independent play and peer conflict resolution, there are several advantages for children to have these experiences, such as:
- Developing social and emotional skills. Independent play and peer conflict resolution can help children develop skills such as cooperation, communication, negotiation, empathy, perspective-taking, self-regulation, and problem-solving. These skills are essential for building positive and lasting relationships with others, as well as for coping with stress and challenges in life. ¹²³
- Enhancing cognitive and creative abilities. Independent play and peer conflict resolution can stimulate children's curiosity, imagination, and exploration, as well as their logical and critical thinking. Children can learn to generate their own ideas, questions, and solutions, as well as to evaluate and modify them based on feedback and evidence. These abilities are crucial for fostering innovation and learning in various domains. ⁴⁵
- Promoting autonomy and agency. Independent play and peer conflict resolution can empower children to make their own choices, express their own opinions, and act on their own interests and goals. Children can learn to respect themselves and others, as well as to take responsibility for their actions and consequences. These qualities are important for developing a sense of self and identity, as well as for achieving personal and social well-being. ⁶⁷
However, independent play and peer conflict resolution do not mean that adults should be completely absent or passive in children's play experiences. Rather, adults should play a supportive and facilitative role, by providing a safe and stimulating environment, offering appropriate materials and resources, observing and listening to children's play, and intervening only when necessary or invited by the children. ⁸⁹
By doing so, adults can help children maximize the benefits of independent play and peer conflict resolution, while minimizing the risks of harm or frustration. Adults can also model and scaffold positive and respectful behaviors, such as asking for permission, sharing, apologizing, or compromising, and praise and reinforce children's efforts and achievements in resolving conflicts.
In conclusion, independent play and peer conflict resolution are valuable and meaningful experiences for preschool and kindergarten children, as they can foster their holistic development and well-being. Adults can support and enhance these experiences by creating and maintaining a playful and respectful atmosphere, where children can freely and safely explore, learn, create, and express themselves, as well as interact and cooperate with their peers.
Source accessed on 11/29/2023
(1) 7 Ways to Teach Kids to Manage Their Own Conflicts | Edutopia. https://www.edutopia.org/article/7-ways-teach-kids-manage-their-own-conflicts
(2) Teaching Kids How to Deal With Conflict - Child Mind Institute. https://childmind.org/article/teaching-kids-how-to-deal-with-conflict/
(3) How to Teach Conflict Resolution to Preschoolers - U-GRO. https://www.u-gro.com/blog/2018/08/how-to-teach-conflict-resolution-to-preschoolers/
(4) The Power of Play: A Pediatric Role in Enhancing Development in Young .... https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/142/3/e20182058/38649/The-Power-of-Play-A-Pediatric-Role-in-Enhancing
(5) Ways Child Care Providers Can Teach Young Children to ... - Extension. https://childcare.extension.org/ways-child-care-providers-can-teach-young-children-to-resolve-conflicts/
(6) Adult intervention levels in young children’s free play: an .... https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10212-021-00560-2
(7) The power of play – Part 5: Adult roles in child’s play. https://www.canr.msu.edu/news/the_power_of_play_part_5_adult_roles_in_childs_play
(8) A playworker’s guide to risk - BeActiveKids. http://www.beactivekids.org/assets/pdf/A_Playworkers_guide_to_risk2.pdf
(9) To Intervene or Not to Intervene? That Is the Question - US News Health. https://health.usnews.com/wellness/for-parents/articles/2018-03-30/to-intervene-or-not-to-intervene-that-is-the-question
